Did Debbie Reynolds die of broken-heart syndrome?
Dying of a broken heart is real.
When Debbie Reynolds passed away this week, her son said the stress of his sister Carrie Fisher’s death the day before was too much for his mother to take.
The emotional distress of losing a loved one can trigger broken-heart syndrome, a recognized medical condition that disproportionately affects women and can be fatal.
“I have had patients come to the hospital after attending a funeral of a loved one. I’ve even had a patient in a situation after an extreme argument with a very close relative,” said Dr. Beth Abramson, a cardiologist at St. Michael’s Hospital and Associate Professor of Medicine at the University of Toronto.
“A ‘broken heart’ really is an event where the heart ceases to function normally and is prone to heart rhythm abnormalities,” said Dr. Mark Creager, director of the Dartmouth-Hitchcock Heart and Vascular Center in New Hampshire and past president of the American Heart Association.
“That term is used to explain a very real phenomenon that does occur in patients who have been exposed to sudden emotional stress or extremely devastating circumstances.”
- ‘She wanted to be with Carrie’: Actress Debbie Reynolds dead at 84
- Star Wars actress, bestselling author Carrie Fisher dead at 60
- Debbie Reynolds, Carrie Fisher died just before HBO film on their lives
Known medically as stress-induced cardiomyopathy or takotsubo syndrome, it can strike anyone, even those in good health with no previous heart problems.
Reynolds, who suffered two strokes in 2015 but recovered, was taken by ambulance to a hospital the day after Fisher died.
“She said, ‘I want to be with Carrie,”‘ Reynolds’ son, Todd Fisher, told The Associated Press. “And then she was gone.”
No cause of death has been disclosed for either woman.
Often confused with heart attacks
The heart doesn’t literally break in times of grief, of course. The turn of phrase comes from the 1611 King James version of the Bible: “The Lord if nigh unto them that are of a broken heart; and saveth such as be of a contrite spirit,” according to Psalms 34:18.
Broken-heart syndrome is when a surge of stress hormones, such as adrenaline and cortisol, cause arteries to seize, limiting blood flow to the heart. The experience — and diagnosis — is often confused with heart attack, Creager said.
Both conditions look the same on an electrocardiogram, said cardiologist Dr. Holly Andersen, director of education for the heart institute at New York Presbyterian Hospital and scientific adviser for the Women’s Heart Alliance. But where heart attacks are caused by blocked arteries, there are no such blockages in “broken” hearts.
The condition can be treated, and even heal untreated, she said, but it can also cause heart arrhythmias and sudden death.
Japanese researchers were the first to describe broken-heart syndrome in 1990. They named it takotsubo, which means “octopus pot,” for the way the malfunctioning heart appears in imaging studies.
Andersen has not treated Reynolds, but she suspects the actress succumbed to “a cardiovascular event,” noting Reynolds’ history of stroke and the prevalence of heart disease among women.
“It wouldn’t be surprising that an 84-year-old woman like Debbie Reynolds had some (arterial) plaque, and with this kind of stress, became more vulnerable and had more of a garden-variety heart attack and sudden death,” Andersen said. “But you don’t have to have any predisposing disease and you could be still susceptible to sudden death from (takotsubo) syndrome because of overwhelming emotional stress.”
A 2014 study out of St George’s University of London suggests that the “garden variety” of trauma can occur after a devastating emotional event, not just takotsubo syndrome. It found that people aged 60 to 89 years old were twice as likely to suffer a heart attack or stroke up to 30 days after a loved one had died.
“We often use the term a ‘broken heart’ to signify the pain of losing a loved one, and our study shows that bereavement can have a direct effect on the health of the heart,” said co-author Dr. Sunil Shah.
’Too many women die of heart disease’
Barbra Streisand, an advocate for women’s cardiovascular health, said in a statement Thursday that “too many women die of heart disease and stroke like mother and child Debbie Reynolds and Carrie Fisher.”
Streisand gave $10 million US in 2012 to create her namesake Women’s Heart Center at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, a research and treatment facility. Heart disease is the No. 1 killer of women, but until recently, research has been done almost exclusively on men.
Women’s hearts are smaller and beat faster at rest than men’s, Andersen said: “There’s no question that, physiologically, when you put everything together — the nerves and the blood vessels — that (women’s) hearts work differently and get disease differently.”
“We need to study more women,” she said. “We’re under-researched. We’re under-treated. But even if you control for all the differences that we know about, we’re still more likely to die from heart disease than a man.”
Carrie Fisher reportedly suffered a heart attack aboard a flight that led to her death four days later.
Women also get other forms of heart disease more frequently than men, Creager said. Takotsubo syndrome is one example.
Abramson notes that a woman’s risk of a heart attack and stroke — as well as other risk factors that might contribute to either, including high blood pressure or cholesterol — increases after midlife or menopause.
“Although the timing of the deaths suggest there may be something else going on, I can’t tell unless we hear an autopsy report,” she told CBC News.
Abramson says researchers know relatively little about takotsubo syndrome compared to the much more common heart attack and stroke.
“It is a less well-defined medical issue. Takotsubo is a rare condition, [while] heart attacks and strokes are very common problems in the general population,” she said.
Scientists don’t know exactly why takotsubo syndrome primarily affects women, but they think it has something to do with the female stress response and the way women’s brains and bodies process emotions.
If fans of Debbie Reynolds and Carrie Fisher want to take a health lesson from the women’s tragic, successive deaths, Creager and Andersen hope it will be recognized as the literal vulnerability of women’s hearts. Forty per cent of women don’t experience chest pain during a heart attack, Andersen said, and a recent survey showed that women often neglect to call 911 even when they think they are having a heart attack.
“The majority know that something’s wrong,” Andersen said. “Jaw pain, back pain, sweating, an overwhelming sense of fatigue. There’s a feeling that something’s wrong. It could be shortness of breath or crazy indigestion. But we’d much rather be taking care of acid reflux or indigestion in the emergency room than missing a heart attack, so please come in if you think something’s wrong.
“You really can die of a broken heart.”